Nvidia's nonstop drama is keeping buyers away from a historically cheap stock

LongbridgeAII'm LongbridgeAI. Here is the key information I extracted
- Nvidia's stock has plunged 47.5% over 6 weeks and its P/E ratio fell to an 8.2 low, despite strong third-quarter results and booming chip demand.
- Wall Street analysts advise against attempting to buy the dip due to profound uncertainties surrounding the abrupt departure of CEO Jensen Huang and regulatory investigations.…
Disclaimer

By Tomi Kilgore and Christine Ji

The stock looks more like a falling knife than a bargain as the Jensen Huang saga drags on, so put the stock on the 'too hard' pile, analyst says

Uncertainties over how the Jensen Huang drama plays out should keep investors from trying to pick a bottom in Nvidia's stock, no matter how cheap it gets.

If you're tempted to try to pick a bottom in Nvidia's stock, after it lost nearly half its value in a little over a month, some Wall Street veterans have some advice for you - just don't do it.

And although demand for Nvidia's chips is still as strong as ever, at a time when valuations have plunged to a 24-year low, analysts believe the stock looks more like a falling knife, that could hurt too much to try to catch, than a bargain.

The stock (NVDA) tumbled 22.9% this past week, its worst weekly performance since the week ended Oct. 10, 2008, according to Dow Jones Market Data. It has plunged 47.5% since closing at a record high about six weeks ago, and has continued to slice through key technical chart levels like they were butter.

On Friday, the stock closed below a trendline that had defined the stock's uptrend since the 2022 bottom, which followed a year-long bear market that saw the stock lose two-thirds of its value.

The first instinct might be to look for the next technical support level, or to now look for where valuations may bottom. But investors should fight the urge.

"This is not a time to rely on technicals or fundamentals," said Mike O'Rourke, chief market strategist at JonesTrading.

Cheap can always get cheaper

On the surface, Nvidia's business is booming. Earlier this week, Nvidia posted third-quarter results that surpassed Wall Street's expectations and projected fourth-quarter revenue of $130 billion, comfortably ahead of the $125 billion consensus estimate.

At the same time, Nvidia's stock hasn't been this cheap since the lows seen after the dot-com bust. The ratio of stock price to analysts' earnings estimates over the next 12 months - the P/E ratio - fell to 8.2 on Friday, which is the lowest since August 2002, according to FactSet.

But sometimes a stock is cheap for a reason. For Nvidia, the reason is uncertainty, particularly about how bad the Jensen Huang fiasco can get now that regulators have gotten involved.

"Growth stocks don't trade on valuation - they trade on the market's confidence and their ability to live up to expectations," Derek Izuel, CIO of Shelton Capital Management, told MarketWatch over email.

After Huang resigned from the CEO position last week amid swirling reports of extramarital relationships and questions over whether restricted AI chips reached China, the company is in choppy waters.

One of the women that he had a relationship with is Alice Huang, a director at the Singaporean data-center firm Megaspeed. Megaspeed had arranged for several billion dollars' worth of Nvidia chips to be sent to China between March 2024 and June 2025, according to the Wall Street Journal. Jensen Huang has agreed to testify in front of several congressional committees on Dec. 1.

Currently, Chief Financial Officer Colette Kress is serving as interim CEO as the board searches for a successor. Even as the board explicitly said Huang would not be coming back, other prominent tech leaders and President Donald Trump have called for his reinstatement.

"There will continue to be a considerable amount of noise around this stock, particularly given its profile in the investing and media landscape," Izuel said. "Trying to find triggers for a bottom right now would be purely speculation."

Put Nvidia's stock on the 'too hard' pile

Rather than try to figure out what could happen next, and how cheap is cheap enough to buy the stock, O'Rourke recommends investors do what Warren Buffett's right-hand man Charlie Munger used to say - put it on the "too hard" pile.

When those legendary investors mulled over what to buy, they would rank the opportunities into three piles - yes, no and too hard to understand. So while Nvidia's stock isn't a no, given how cheap it is, it's also not a yes, considering the price action and all the uncertainty surrounding the company.

As O'Rourke explained, the "too hard" pile would mean to do nothing, until there's some fundamental clarity and prices start to stabilize.

In other words, wait for the knife to stop falling before you try to pick it up.

-Tomi Kilgore -Christine Ji

This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

11-21-26 0830ET

Login to unlock3,345characters for free

Due to copyright restrictions, please log in to your Longbridge account to view this content.
Thank you for your understanding and support of licensed content.