Tesla's Automotive Revenue Fell 3%, and Energy Generation and Storage Tumbled 16%. Should Investors Still View Tesla as a Car Company?
I'm LongbridgeAI, I can summarize articles.Tesla's automotive revenue fell 3% and energy storage dropped 16%, while services grew 33%. Despite flat vehicle sales, Tesla maintains a $1.5 trillion market cap driven by investor optimism in autonomous driving (FSD) and the Optimus robot. However, with profits already baked into the high valuation, the article argues Tesla remains fundamentally a car company. It suggests avoiding the stock until new products prove they can generate the expected $50 billion annual profit.
Defining Tesla (TSLA -3.08%) has always been a challenging question for investors.
As an electric-vehicle maker, Tesla has never traded like a typical car company. Legacy automakers like General Motors and Ford tend to trade for single-digit price-to-earnings ratios, even though these companies bring in boatloads of profits most years.
Five years ago, investors seemed assured that electric vehicles would disrupt the whole auto market and that combustion vehicles would be left in the past. However, that hasn't happened, and Tesla's vehicle sales have been basically flat over the last three years. Meanwhile, GM and Ford have pulled back from their own efforts in EVs.
After three years of flat vehicle sales, you might expect Tesla stock to swoon, but instead it has kept pace with the S&P 500, climbing to a market cap of $1.5 trillion.
Tesla has managed to do that largely by shifting investor focus away from EVs and to the future.
Image source: Tesla.
Elon Musk's sleight of hand
Tesla CEO Elon Musk is known for making big promises. He has a reputation for being late, but eventually delivering on those.
After taking Tesla's EV business mainstream against long odds, Musk now sees the future of the company in autonomy, specifically with autonomous vehicles built on the company's full self-driving technology, and its Optimus autonomous robot, which is in development.
On the third-quarter earnings call, Musk said that he believed Optimus would become "the biggest product ever." Tesla is currently working to scale production to 20,000 units a week, and it predicted that initial customer deliveries would begin around the end of 2027. Most CEOs wouldn't move the needle with such a prediction, and would likely be reluctant to make one, but Musk has built up enough credibility with investors that they're willing to bet on those forecasts.
Similarly, the Tesla chief said that full self-driving (FSD), Tesla's autonomous vehicle system which still requires human supervision, is the biggest driver of Tesla demand, and even predicted that Tesla would perform the majority of passenger miles in countries where it's allowed to operate with FSD.
With bombastic statements like that from Musk, perhaps it's not surprising that the currently no-growth company trades at a price-to-earnings ratio of 200.
TSLA - Tesla
NASDAQ · As of 4:00 PM ET 10/22/26
Moneyball Superscore65/100Key data points
Is Tesla a car company?
Tesla's revenue in the second quarter fell by 0.2% to $28 billion, with automotive revenue down 3% to $20.6 billion, while energy generation and storage revenue slipped 16% to $2.88 billion. Services were the only one of its three segments to grow, with revenue up 33% to $4.6 billion.
Profits fell as the company continues to invest in AI and next-gen products like Optimus.
With nearly three-quarters of its revenue still coming from its vehicles, Tesla is a car company by any reasonable definition. However, the company has been able to separate its valuation from its current status as a no-growth car company.
Tesla's investments in Optimus, FSD, and AI are clearly worth something, but it remains to be seen whether they can reach significant scale, since huge profits from those businesses are already baked into the price.
Considering that, and Tesla's own struggles to continue growing its auto business, the stock looks best avoided at this point. At Tesla's current market cap, investors expect it to grow its annual profit to at least $50 billion, based on valuations of its big tech peers. That will either have to come from new products like Optimus or from the renewed growth of its auto business.
Even if Optimus is a success, it will take several years for the company to reach $50 billion in annual profit, given that its current annual revenue is just $120 billion. Until Tesla proves it's more than a car company, the math just doesn't add up.